Why Car Wear-and-Tear Makes Errands More Expensive
When calculating errand costs, most people think about gas. But car wear and tear adds significant hidden expenses that make errands more expensive than they appear. Understanding these costs reveals the true price of driving for returns and other errands.
The Hidden Vehicle Costs
What People See
Obvious Costs:
- Gas: $3-8 per trip
- Parking: $0-10 per trip
- Total: $3-18
What They Miss:
- Depreciation
- Wear and tear
- Maintenance acceleration
- Hidden costs: $4-12 per trip
Depreciation: The Biggest Hidden Cost
How It Works
Every Mile Counts:
- Car loses value with every mile
- Average: $0.25-0.50 per mile
- 10-mile trip: $2.50-5.00
- Real expense
Why It Matters:
- Reduces car's resale value
- Real financial loss
- Often ignored
- Significant cost
The Math
Per Return Trip:
- Average distance: 10 miles
- Depreciation: $2.50-5.00
- Hidden cost
Monthly (3 returns):
- 30 miles
- Depreciation: $7.50-15
- Monthly hidden cost
Annual (36 returns):
- 360 miles
- Depreciation: $90-180
- Annual hidden cost
Wear and Tear: Accelerated Maintenance
How It Works
More Miles = More Maintenance:
- Oil changes come sooner
- Tires wear faster
- Brakes need replacement
- General wear accelerates
The Cost:
- $0.10-0.20 per mile
- 10-mile trip: $1-2
- Real maintenance cost
The Impact
Per Return Trip:
- 10 miles: $1-2 wear cost
- Hidden expense
Monthly (3 returns):
- 30 miles: $3-6 wear cost
- Monthly hidden cost
Annual (36 returns):
- 360 miles: $36-72 wear cost
- Annual hidden cost
Maintenance Acceleration
Oil Changes
Normal Schedule:
- Every 5,000-7,500 miles
- Regular maintenance
With Extra Errands:
- Come 360 miles sooner (per year)
- One extra change every 14-21 years
- Accelerated cost
Tire Replacement
Normal Life:
- 40,000-60,000 miles
- Lasts years
With Extra Errands:
- Wear 360 miles faster per year
- Replace slightly sooner
- Accelerated cost
Brake Replacement
Normal Life:
- 30,000-70,000 miles
- Varies by driving
With Extra Errands:
- More stops and starts
- Wear faster
- Replace sooner
- Accelerated cost
The Complete Vehicle Cost
Per Return Trip
Depreciation:
- $2.50-5.00 (10 miles)
Wear and Tear:
- $1-2 (10 miles)
Maintenance Acceleration:
- $0.50-1.00 (estimated)
Total Vehicle Cost: $4-8 per return
Monthly (3 Returns)
Vehicle Costs:
- $4-8 × 3 = $12-24
- Monthly hidden cost
Annual (36 Returns)
Vehicle Costs:
- $4-8 × 36 = $144-288
- Annual hidden cost
The Complete Errand Cost
True Cost Per Return
Direct Costs:
- Gas: $3-8
- Parking: $0-5
- Subtotal: $3-13
Vehicle Costs:
- Depreciation: $2.50-5.00
- Wear: $1-2
- Maintenance: $0.50-1.00
- Subtotal: $4-8
Time Costs:
- 90 minutes: $37.50-150 (at $25-100/hour)
- Subtotal: $37.50-150
Total: $44.50-171 per return
The Hidden Portion
Vehicle Costs: $4-8 (9-18% of total) Significant hidden expense
The Comparison
DIY Return True Cost
Complete Cost:
- Direct: $3-13
- Vehicle: $4-8
- Time: $37.50-150
- Total: $44.50-171
Pickup Service Cost
Service Fee:
- $20-25 per pickup
Time Cost:
- 90 seconds: $1.25
Vehicle Cost:
- $0 (no driving)
Total: $21.25-26.25
Savings: $23.25-144.75 per return
Real-World Impact
Monthly (3 Returns)
DIY Vehicle Costs:
- $12-24 per month
- Hidden expense
Pickup Service:
- $0 vehicle costs
- Eliminated
Monthly Vehicle Savings: $12-24
Annual (36 Returns)
DIY Vehicle Costs:
- $144-288 per year
- Hidden expense
Pickup Service:
- $0 vehicle costs
- Eliminated
Annual Vehicle Savings: $144-288
The Compound Effect
Over Vehicle Lifetime
5 Years of Returns:
- 180 returns
- 1,800 miles
- Depreciation: $450-900
- Wear: $180-360
- Total: $630-1,260
10 Years of Returns:
- 360 returns
- 3,600 miles
- Depreciation: $900-1,800
- Wear: $360-720
- Total: $1,260-2,520
Significant vehicle cost over time
Making the Calculation
Step 1: Calculate Miles
Per Return:
- Distance to location
- Round trip
- Total miles
Step 2: Calculate Depreciation
Formula:
- Miles × $0.25-0.50
- Depreciation cost
Step 3: Calculate Wear
Formula:
- Miles × $0.10-0.20
- Wear cost
Step 4: Add to Other Costs
Total:
- Gas + Parking + Depreciation + Wear
- Complete vehicle cost
The Bottom Line
Car wear and tear adds $4-8 per return trip in hidden costs from depreciation, wear, and accelerated maintenance. Over a year, this adds $144-288 in vehicle costs that most people don't realize they're paying.
When you factor in vehicle costs, DIY returns cost $44.50-171 per return, while pickup services cost $21.25-26.25. The savings are clear: $23.25-144.75 per return, plus $144-288 per year in vehicle costs eliminated.
If you're driving for returns, calculate your vehicle costs. You'll likely find that pickup services save money on gas, time, and vehicle wear—making them the better choice.
Ready to eliminate vehicle costs? Check Returnful's service and stop paying hidden vehicle expenses.
Want to see your vehicle costs? Text us at 469-790-7579 for a personalized calculation!
Written by
Returnful Team
Part of the Returnful team, helping DFW residents save time on their online returns with same-day pickup service.
Get Return Tips in Your Inbox
Weekly tips to save time on returns. No spam.


