Myth: "Doing It Myself Saves Money" — Not Always
"Doing it yourself saves money" is conventional wisdom, but it's not always true. When you factor in your time value, opportunity cost, and hidden expenses, DIY often costs more than professional services. Here's when DIY actually costs you money and why outsourcing can be the smarter financial choice.
The DIY Assumption
The Common Belief
The Thinking:
- "I can do it myself"
- "It's free if I do it"
- "Why pay someone else?"
- "I'm saving money"
The Logic:
- No service fee
- Do the work yourself
- Keep the money
- Seems smart
The Problem:
- Ignores time value
- Ignores opportunity cost
- Ignores hidden expenses
- Incomplete calculation
The True Cost of DIY
What DIY Really Costs
Direct Costs:
- Materials and supplies
- Gas and transportation
- Parking fees
- Tools and equipment
- Visible expenses
Time Costs:
- Hours invested
- Your hourly value
- Time × Value = Cost
- Often largest cost
Opportunity Costs:
- Income not earned
- Skills not learned
- Relationships not built
- Growth not achieved
- Hidden but real
Stress Costs:
- Mental load
- Frustration
- Energy depletion
- Health impact
- Quality of life cost
The Return Example
DIY Return Cost
Time Investment:
- 90 minutes average
- At $50/hour: $75
- At $100/hour: $150
- At $200/hour: $300
Direct Costs:
- Gas: $5
- Parking: $3
- Subtotal: $8
Opportunity Cost:
- Could have worked: $75-300
- Could have done valuable task
- Lost productivity
- Subtotal: $75-300
Stress Cost:
- Mental load: $20
- Energy: $10
- Subtotal: $30
Total DIY Cost: $88-338
Professional Service Cost
Service Fee:
- $20-25 per return
- All-inclusive
- Professional handling
Time Investment:
- 90 seconds
- At $50/hour: $1.25
- At $100/hour: $2.50
Total Service Cost: $21.25-27.50
The Comparison
DIY: $88-338 Service: $21.25-27.50 Savings with Service: $60.75-310.50
Service is 75-92% cheaper!
When DIY Costs More
High Time Value
If You Earn $50+/Hour:
- DIY costs more than service
- Time value exceeds service fee
- Service saves money
- Clear financial win
Example:
- Professional earning $100/hour
- DIY return: $150 time cost
- Service: $22
- Saves $128 by using service
High Opportunity Cost
If Your Time Is Valuable:
- Could earn more working
- Could advance career
- Could build business
- Opportunity cost high
Example:
- Entrepreneur
- Time could grow business
- DIY return: $200 opportunity cost
- Service: $22
- Saves $178 by using service
Multiple Tasks
If You Have Many Returns:
- DIY: Each takes 90 minutes
- 5 returns: 7.5 hours
- Time cost: $375-750
- Service: $100-125
- Saves $250-625
Stress and Health
If Stress Affects You:
- DIY creates stress
- Health impact
- Reduced productivity
- Quality of life cost
Example:
- High-stress person
- DIY return: Stress cost $50
- Service: No stress
- Saves $50 in stress cost
When DIY Might Save Money
Low Time Value
If Time Has No Value:
- Retired with free time
- Unemployed
- Time truly has no opportunity cost
- DIY might save
Reality Check:
- Even then, stress matters
- Quality of life matters
- Often still worth service
Already Going There
If Location Is On Route:
- Already driving past
- No extra trip
- Minimal time added
- DIY might make sense
But Consider:
- Still takes time at location
- Lines and waiting
- Often still not worth it
Enjoy the Task
If You Actually Enjoy It:
- Some people enjoy errands
- Find it relaxing
- Personal preference
- DIY makes sense
Reality:
- Very few people enjoy returns
- Most find it stressful
- Rare exception
The Break-Even Analysis
Finding Your Break-Even Point
The Formula:
- Service cost: $20-25
- Time saved: 90 minutes (1.5 hours)
- Break-even: $20-25 ÷ 1.5 = $13.33-16.67/hour
If Your Time Is Worth More Than $15/Hour:
- Service saves money
- DIY costs more
- Clear choice
Most Professionals:
- Earn $25-200/hour
- Well above break-even
- Service always cheaper
- Obvious decision
Real-World Examples
Example 1: Software Engineer
Profile:
- Earns $150/hour
- Works from home
- Values focus time
DIY Return:
- Time: 90 minutes
- Cost: $225
- Plus gas: $5
- Plus stress: $30
- Total: $260
Service:
- Cost: $22
- Time: 90 seconds ($3.75)
- Total: $25.75
Saves: $234.25 per return
Example 2: Consultant
Profile:
- Billable rate: $200/hour
- Every hour billable
- Time is money
DIY Return:
- Time: 90 minutes
- Lost billing: $300
- Plus expenses: $8
- Total: $308
Service:
- Cost: $22
- Time: 90 seconds ($5)
- Total: $27
Saves: $281 per return
Example 3: Stay-at-Home Parent
Profile:
- Time value: $50/hour (if working)
- Must take kids
- Adds 30 minutes
DIY Return:
- Time: 120 minutes
- Cost: $100
- Plus gas: $5
- Plus snacks: $8
- Plus stress: $50
- Total: $163
Service:
- Cost: $22
- Time: 90 seconds ($1.25)
- Total: $23.25
Saves: $139.75 per return
The Annual Math
Monthly Comparison
3 Returns Per Month:
DIY:
- Time: 4.5 hours
- Cost: $264-1,014
- Stress: High
Service:
- Time: 4.5 minutes
- Cost: $63-81
- Stress: None
Monthly Savings: $183-933
Annual Comparison
36 Returns Per Year:
DIY:
- Time: 54 hours
- Cost: $3,168-12,168
- Stress: Constant
Service:
- Time: 54 minutes
- Cost: $756-972
- Stress: None
Annual Savings: $2,196-11,196
The Compound Effect
Career Impact
Time Reclaimed:
- 54 hours per year
- Could work extra hours
- Could advance skills
- Could build network
Potential Income:
- Extra work: $2,700-10,800
- Career advancement: Potentially more
- Skills development: Long-term value
- Compound benefits
Quality of Life
Stress Reduction:
- Better health
- More energy
- Better relationships
- Improved well-being
Value:
- Health: Priceless
- Relationships: Invaluable
- Well-being: Essential
- Worth more than money
Making the Smart Choice
Calculate Your True Cost
The Process:
- Time investment × Your hourly value
- Add direct costs
- Add opportunity cost
- Add stress value
- Compare to service cost
The Decision:
- If DIY costs more: Use service
- If service costs more: Consider DIY
- Factor in quality of life
- Make informed choice
Consider All Factors
Don't Just Look At:
- Service fee
- Visible costs
- Surface comparison
Also Consider:
- Time value
- Opportunity cost
- Stress impact
- Quality of life
- Long-term benefits
Conclusion: DIY Isn't Always Cheaper
"Doing it yourself saves money" is a myth when your time has value. For most professionals earning $25+/hour, DIY returns cost $88-338 while services cost $21-27. The math is clear: services save money, not DIY.
The key is calculating your true cost—time value, opportunity cost, and hidden expenses. When you do the complete math, professional services often win financially while also saving time and reducing stress.
Don't assume DIY saves money. Calculate your true cost, compare to services, and make the financially smart choice. Your wallet will thank you.
Ready to see if DIY or service saves you money? Check Returnful's pricing and calculate your true cost.
Calculate your true DIY cost. Text us at 469-790-7579 for a personalized comparison!
Written by
Returnful Team
Part of the Returnful team, helping DFW residents save time on their online returns with same-day pickup service.
Get Return Tips in Your Inbox
Weekly tips to save time on returns. No spam.
