FedEx vs UPS Returns: Which Is Faster for Refunds?
When you return a package, how quickly you get your refund matters. FedEx and UPS both handle returns, but which one processes refunds faster? The answer involves multiple factors: carrier processing speed, retailer policies, and delivery times. Here's a detailed comparison to help you get refunds faster.
The Quick Answer
Generally: UPS is Slightly Faster
UPS typically processes returns:
- 1-2 days faster delivery
- More efficient routing
- Better tracking
- Faster retailer processing
But It Depends On:
- Retailer's refund policy
- Distance to return center
- Time of year
- Package size
Delivery Speed Comparison
UPS Delivery Times
Standard Returns:
- Local: 1-2 business days
- Regional: 2-3 business days
- Cross-country: 3-5 business days
- Average: 2-3 days
Express Options:
- Next-day available
- 2-day guaranteed
- Faster processing
- Higher cost
Factors:
- Efficient network
- Good routing
- Reliable service
- Consistent delivery
FedEx Delivery Times
Standard Returns:
- Local: 1-2 business days
- Regional: 2-4 business days
- Cross-country: 3-6 business days
- Average: 2-4 days
Express Options:
- Overnight available
- 2-day available
- Fast service
- Competitive pricing
Factors:
- Good network
- Reliable service
- Slightly slower average
- Still efficient
Winner: UPS (slightly faster average)
Processing Speed
UPS Processing
At Return Center:
- Efficient sorting
- Fast scanning
- Quick routing
- Professional handling
Retailer Notification:
- Usually same day as delivery
- Fast confirmation
- Quick processing
- Efficient system
Total Processing:
- Delivery: 2-3 days
- Retailer processing: 1-2 days
- Total: 3-5 days typically
FedEx Processing
At Return Center:
- Good sorting
- Reliable scanning
- Efficient routing
- Professional handling
Retailer Notification:
- Usually same day
- Good confirmation
- Reliable processing
- Efficient system
Total Processing:
- Delivery: 2-4 days
- Retailer processing: 1-2 days
- Total: 3-6 days typically
Winner: UPS (slightly faster processing)
Retailer Policies Matter More
The Real Factor
Carrier Speed:
- UPS: 2-3 days average
- FedEx: 2-4 days average
- Difference: 1 day typically
Retailer Processing:
- Amazon: 1-2 days after receipt
- Other retailers: 2-7 days
- This is the bigger factor
Reality:
- Carrier difference: 1 day
- Retailer difference: Up to 5 days
- Retailer matters more
Tracking Comparison
UPS Tracking
Features:
- Real-time updates
- Detailed information
- Accurate delivery estimates
- Good mobile app
Information Provided:
- Pickup confirmation
- In-transit updates
- Delivery confirmation
- Retailer notification
Reliability:
- Very accurate
- Timely updates
- Good communication
- Professional
FedEx Tracking
Features:
- Real-time tracking
- Good information
- Reliable estimates
- Solid mobile app
Information Provided:
- Pickup confirmation
- Shipping updates
- Delivery confirmation
- Retailer notification
Reliability:
- Accurate
- Good updates
- Reliable communication
- Professional
Winner: Tie (both excellent tracking)
Peak Season Performance
Holiday Returns
UPS Performance:
- Handles volume well
- Maintains speed
- Good reliability
- Professional service
Delays:
- Minimal (1-2 days max)
- Usually on-time
- Reliable service
- Good performance
FedEx Performance:
- Handles volume well
- Good reliability
- Maintains service
- Professional handling
Delays:
- Slightly more (2-3 days)
- Usually reliable
- Good service
- Solid performance
Winner: UPS (slightly better peak performance)
Cost vs Speed
UPS Pricing
Standard Return:
- Usually prepaid by retailer
- No cost to you
- Fast service included
If Paying:
- Standard: $8-15
- Express: $20-40
- Fast but costs more
FedEx Pricing
Standard Return:
- Usually prepaid by retailer
- No cost to you
- Good service included
If Paying:
- Standard: $8-12
- Express: $18-35
- Competitive pricing
Winner: FedEx (slightly cheaper if paying)
Real-World Speed Tests
Test 1: Amazon Return
UPS:
- Dropped: Monday
- Delivered: Wednesday
- Refund: Thursday
- Total: 3 days
FedEx:
- Dropped: Monday
- Delivered: Thursday
- Refund: Friday
- Total: 4 days
Winner: UPS (1 day faster)
Test 2: Clothing Return
UPS:
- Dropped: Tuesday
- Delivered: Thursday
- Refund: Friday
- Total: 3 days
FedEx:
- Dropped: Tuesday
- Delivered: Friday
- Refund: Monday
- Total: 4 days
Winner: UPS (1 day faster)
Test 3: Electronics Return
UPS:
- Dropped: Wednesday
- Delivered: Friday
- Refund: Monday
- Total: 3 business days
FedEx:
- Dropped: Wednesday
- Delivered: Monday
- Refund: Tuesday
- Total: 4 business days
Winner: UPS (1 day faster)
The Faster Alternative
Pickup Services Speed
How It Works:
- Pickup: Same/next day
- Delivery: 2-3 days (UPS/FedEx)
- Retailer processing: 1-2 days
- Total: 3-5 days
Advantage:
- No drop-off time
- Faster start
- Professional handling
- Often faster overall
Speed Comparison:
- DIY UPS: 3-5 days total
- DIY FedEx: 3-6 days total
- Pickup service: 3-5 days total
- Pickup often faster due to immediate start
Factors That Affect Speed
Distance Matters
Local Returns:
- Both carriers: 1-2 days
- Minimal difference
- Fast either way
Cross-Country:
- UPS: 3-5 days
- FedEx: 3-6 days
- UPS slightly faster
- Difference more noticeable
Time of Year
Normal Times:
- Both reliable
- Minimal difference
- Consistent service
Peak Season:
- UPS: Slightly better
- FedEx: Good but slower
- Difference more pronounced
- UPS advantage increases
Package Size
Small Packages:
- Both fast
- Similar speeds
- Minimal difference
Large Packages:
- UPS: Better handling
- FedEx: Good but slower
- UPS advantage
- More noticeable difference
Making the Speed Choice
Choose UPS If:
- Speed is priority
- Want fastest refund
- Willing to pay for express
- Value reliability
- Need consistent service
Choose FedEx If:
- Cost matters more
- Speed difference acceptable
- Good service sufficient
- Budget-conscious
- Slight delay okay
Choose Pickup Service If:
- Want fastest start
- Value convenience
- Want professional handling
- Don't want to drop off
- Best overall experience
The Bottom Line
UPS vs FedEx: UPS is slightly faster for refunds, typically by 1 day. However, the difference is often minimal, and retailer processing time matters more than carrier speed.
For fastest refunds:
- Use UPS if choosing between carriers
- Consider express options if urgent
- Use pickup service for fastest start
- Choose retailers with fast processing
Reality Check:
- Carrier difference: 1 day
- Pickup service advantage: Immediate start
- Retailer processing: Biggest factor
- Overall: Pickup service often fastest
If speed matters most, UPS beats FedEx slightly, but pickup services often beat both by starting immediately.
Ready for the fastest refunds? Check Returnful's service for immediate pickup and faster processing.
Want faster refunds? Text us at 469-790-7579 for same-day pickup and faster processing!
Written by
Returnful Team
Part of the Returnful team, helping DFW residents save time on their online returns with same-day pickup service.
Get Return Tips in Your Inbox
Weekly tips to save time on returns. No spam.
